Thank you NC. There was the slight chance that the Listowel contest might offer an early clue for that race but it would appear we will have to first exercise some patience!
PLUMPTON
Preview review
Winner Peat Moss was underestimated on account of his poor recent run and a perceived need for a stiffer test. However, it has been noted that his potential over jumps is greater than that on the flat and with Calidus Mirabilis going off as quickly as he did, the consequent stiffer test in tandem with more suitable waiting tactics helped him realise the potential he had shown. His underestimation was still somewhat perturbing but had the pace not been so exaggerated then he probably would not have had the gears to win this contest. Apart from Peat Moss, the preview was otherwise satisfactory. Bourbali ran well despite some inexperienced jumping early on and emerges as very much the best in the field. Calidus Mirabilis's chances were indeed compromised by the extended distance. Prince Percy once again disappointed following market support and his uncharacteristically below-par effort last time was replicated as he failed to build on his hurdling debut.
Race review
While not an atrocious looking event, those with experience either had questions to answer or looked fair at best. The pace was a solid one which had the field strung out with over a mile still to be ran. Although the winning time was almost four seconds slower than the maiden hurdle later on the card, a hypothetical weight-for-age allowance roughly aligns the two races. The first two in the betting ran below their best but those runs can be accounted for by a dip in form and incorrect tactics. Otherwise, the first three had every right to fill their respective places and the outsiders were beaten a long way from home. Both the winner and the runner-up demonstrated good battling qualities in their race to the line and with an overall reasonable standard of jumping along with a lack of hard luck stories, the form appears to be solid.
Peat Moss is this season's second winner from as many runners in this sphere for both trainer Nigel Hawke and sire Fracas. He had shown little on the flat and was disappointing last time out but his profile suggested that he could do better over hurdles. There was promise on his debut at Newton Abbot and while racing prominently cost him any real chance at Cartmel, a change in tactics and a strong pace set by the leader enabled him to realise his debut potential. A visor introduced at Lingfield was retained here and it likely helped him settle into a nice rhythm in the rear of the field. He has a neat and quiet way of going over his hurdles and while he is not the type to steal a couple of lengths in the air, his style does allow him to conserve energy. Closing on the leaders after the sixth, his run to the line was more a steady gallop than an explosive burst. Nevertheless, he was game in his effort and was able to get his nose in front in the shadow of the post. Peat Moss had previously never finished closer than seven lengths to a winner but he proved today that he is not averse to a battle. This marks a new career best although the race did pan out perfectly for him here and he might struggle under a penalty at this level. Nevertheless, while he probably lacks the scope of the runner up, he put in an honest performance and his better conditions and tactics are now more apparent. 105
Bourbali has a fantastic pedigree for the game and was only just denied a winning debut at the post. He looked calm and well beforehand and he travelled as well as anything from the outset. His jumping was fairly novicey in the early stages and was not entirely fluent at the final two flights. There was nothing alarming about his jumping and he put in some very good leaps in the middle of the race so while there is room for improvement, he already has a decent foundation. Bourbali looked the likeliest winner from some way out and traded as low as 1.08 in running. Much the best of those who raced prominently, he did not lack for willingness in the closing stages and ran straight and true up to the line. It was only really inexperience that cost him the race and he can emerge a fair deal better than this level. This was a most promising debut effort. 105
Treaty Of Dingle was another making her hurdling debut and put in a creditable performance first time. Following three successive seconds, she was claimed out of a Lingfield claimer at long odds-on. With her sex allowance taken into account, she came into the race with the highest flat rating. She was slightly keen early on but apart from a slightly awkward jump at the fourth, put in a decent round and kept on well enough to the line. While she did not quite match her flat standard here, she should be able to reach a similar level over jumps in due course. 92
Calidus Mirabilis had shown enough to suggest he can win a race of this nature during his first two runs in Ireland for Joseph O'Brien. However, his endurance is suspect which made the tactics employed today all the more baffling. Racing prominently is often advantageous in juvenile hurdles although to do so in an aggressive fashion requires completely assured stamina. He was still in the lead right up to the penultimate flight but was headed immediately afterwards and was beaten by over twelve lengths without being eased. Calidus Mirabilis is an adequate jumper but does lack fluency and as in previous outings, his hurdling did deteriorate once his tank began to empty. This outing was less a regression than a misuse of tactics as there was still evidence of his relative capabilities. He does need an easy test to show his best however and he may continue to disappoint in the absence of optimal conditions. 92
Prince Percy made a fair impression on his hurdling debut at Market Rasen back in July but had disappointed in the interim on the flat. He was backed into favouritism here but was pulled up between the final two flights which would make this the fifth time in his latest six starts that he has been unable to justify market support. He was keen early on and while he jumped well on his debut, was slightly slow at the third and got in close to the fifth and sixth before jumping his last flight slowly. He is obviously thought capable of better than this and there is a level over hurdles where he can be competitive. However, his current disposition does not inspire faith and while his being cast in his box during the summer was probably not too damaging, a session on a horse sized psychiatrist's couch might be helpful. 80
Lightning Bug's starting price of 150/1 was a fair reflection of her chances and while she managed to beat the other outsiders, she was a good dozen lengths off the leading quintet when coming to grief three from home. It was not a blunder that caused her demise, rather she crumpled on landing after the flight had been negotiated. While slightly awkward at a couple of her other jumps, it was not the worst round for a newcomer but she still has plenty to prove going forward. 0
Brown Eyed Girl's official flat rating of 51 looked steep for what she had actually achieved but she was bred to be better over hurdles and her trainer has a good record in this race. However, Brown Eyed Girl was keen early on but was already being ridden with a circuit left to run and would tail off before being pulled up three out. She may do better if she learns to settle and her jumping was fine apart from a slow jump at the first but there is nothing immediately promising about her future prospects. 0
Full Secret had shown a modicum of ability on the flat for Richard Fahey and was another representing a trainer whose charges have outran their odds in this race. However, she was even further detached from further out than Brown Eyed Girl and safe jumping aside, offered little encouragement. 0
LISTOWEL
Preview review
Longclaw was expected to win more comfortably than he did but while Scholastic hit 1.02 in running, she was never in front for any more than half a stride. Scholastic jumped considerably better than she had on her previous two starts which enabled her to close the margin between herself and the winner. At War's jumping was decent enough for him to outrun his odds while Little Brother was a little too headstrong to do himself justice. Made In Pimlico's effort was not expected but his trainer does get winners in the division and with him quickly pulling up halfway through his sole start this year, he was somewhat unexposed.
Race review
Today's race at Listowel lost a great deal of its interest when Duffle Coat was withdrawn this morning after reportedly being found sore. Nevertheless, it ended up being more competitive than originally anticipated. A pair of keen and free running horses ensured a solid tempo although the winning time was slowest by standard on the card as well as being slower than any of the previous renewals ran on similar ground. The standard of jumping was generally decent, especially by the first two home, and although the loose horse briefly involved herself in the back straight, there were no real hard luck stories. The first three home give the form a decent endorsement but it is diminished by the proximity of the 125/1 shot Made In Pimlico. In all, the race was a decent quality for the time of year but it looks unlikely to have a great influence on the season's better races.
Longclaw made it three from three and was made to battle for the first time in his hurdling career. He posted his best round of jumping to date and though he lost some momentum after getting in close to the last, was able to rally and fend off his persistent challenger. While the runner-up got very close to him, she was in receipt of seventeen pounds and her jumping had massively improved since her last appearance. The form is still as good as anything he has produced thus far and his demonstration of battling qualities entitles this performance to stand marginally as his best to date. With the exception of stablemate Duffle Coat, he stands nine pounds clear of the rest of Ireland's juveniles for the time being. However, he appears to be reaching the limits of his potential and unless the better types are slow to emerge, he may struggle once he forced to step up in class. 126
Scholastic is no better on the flat than her official mark of 70 at this juncture and her jumping left plenty to be desired coming into this race. However, apart from being slightly slow over the second, there was a considerable improvement in her hurdling here and she was on occasion very slick. She also displayed a good attitude in running to the line and was held by only a narrow margin. On this evidence, she is more than capable of winning a small race and her newfound zest for hurdling may provoke further improvement. Notwithstanding, she was still receiving plenty of weight from the winner and her form is still a long way from pattern class so her aspirations can only be limited for the time being. 109
At War is officially rated 75 on the flat but his recent efforts have not reflected that mark. He did not run to that level on his hurdling debut at Punchestown either but his jumping was good there and he replicated his proficiency again this afternoon. He was keen early and was running freely when extending his lead as he embarked on the second circuit. Nevertheless, his jumping was always slick and his first slight error came after he was impeded by the loose horse approaching the sixth. He was headed soon after but was still able to keep tabs on the leaders and it was only on entering the straight that the first two pulled clear of him. He will need to learn how to settle but he has the engine and the hurdling ability to be a problem at this standard. 105
Made In Pimlico had no right to be involved in the race based on his previous flat form and he got in close to several of his hurdles along the way here. He was pulled up quickly half way through his debut at Tipperary after apparently being hampered so was arguably unexposed in that regard. His trainer also managed two winners from three juvenile hurdlers last season which is an improvement on what he had achieved previously. Furthermore, Made In Pimlico was trying cheekpieces for the first time along with his tongue-tie which is another possible factor in his dramatic improvement. Strictly on this outing, he is capable of being competitive in moderate company but he would perhaps first need to demonstrate that this was not a fluke. 104
Little Brother was the other winner in the field but he had disappointed on his return to the flat and he did not quite match the form of his Bellewstown win here. Despite being a winner over hurdles, he has not been the best jumper and there were a few flights here where he was not entirely fluent. That he was rather headstrong did not help him either despite the reapplication of the cheekpieces he wore when winning on his penultimate start. Nevertheless, the form he has shown today is not too far off his best so there is no reason to suspect any severe regression and he would still be respected in lesser company. 108
Finsceal Blue was one of two racecourse debutants in the field but while his sire has a fair record in the division, he did not have the most compelling profile beforehand. Always towards the rear of the field, his jumping was not especially fluent in the early stages and he began to get detached before the field reached the back straight. It would not be difficult for him to improve on this effort but there was little immediate promise. 49
Social Distancing was the other racecourse debutant and her pedigree suggested that she would be neither sharp nor forward enough for this test. She jumped slowly and was detached early on in the race. She was completely tailed off when she fell at the last and there is nothing encouraging to be drawn from this performance. 0
Waterville Lady represented a trainer with a decent record in this race but she was not especially well supported in the market. She jumped to her right and unseated her rider at the second and was fairly wild when jumping loose over the next. 0
PLUMPTON
Preview review
Winner Peat Moss was underestimated on account of his poor recent run and a perceived need for a stiffer test. However, it has been noted that his potential over jumps is greater than that on the flat and with Calidus Mirabilis going off as quickly as he did, the consequent stiffer test in tandem with more suitable waiting tactics helped him realise the potential he had shown. His underestimation was still somewhat perturbing but had the pace not been so exaggerated then he probably would not have had the gears to win this contest. Apart from Peat Moss, the preview was otherwise satisfactory. Bourbali ran well despite some inexperienced jumping early on and emerges as very much the best in the field. Calidus Mirabilis's chances were indeed compromised by the extended distance. Prince Percy once again disappointed following market support and his uncharacteristically below-par effort last time was replicated as he failed to build on his hurdling debut.
Race review
While not an atrocious looking event, those with experience either had questions to answer or looked fair at best. The pace was a solid one which had the field strung out with over a mile still to be ran. Although the winning time was almost four seconds slower than the maiden hurdle later on the card, a hypothetical weight-for-age allowance roughly aligns the two races. The first two in the betting ran below their best but those runs can be accounted for by a dip in form and incorrect tactics. Otherwise, the first three had every right to fill their respective places and the outsiders were beaten a long way from home. Both the winner and the runner-up demonstrated good battling qualities in their race to the line and with an overall reasonable standard of jumping along with a lack of hard luck stories, the form appears to be solid.
Peat Moss is this season's second winner from as many runners in this sphere for both trainer Nigel Hawke and sire Fracas. He had shown little on the flat and was disappointing last time out but his profile suggested that he could do better over hurdles. There was promise on his debut at Newton Abbot and while racing prominently cost him any real chance at Cartmel, a change in tactics and a strong pace set by the leader enabled him to realise his debut potential. A visor introduced at Lingfield was retained here and it likely helped him settle into a nice rhythm in the rear of the field. He has a neat and quiet way of going over his hurdles and while he is not the type to steal a couple of lengths in the air, his style does allow him to conserve energy. Closing on the leaders after the sixth, his run to the line was more a steady gallop than an explosive burst. Nevertheless, he was game in his effort and was able to get his nose in front in the shadow of the post. Peat Moss had previously never finished closer than seven lengths to a winner but he proved today that he is not averse to a battle. This marks a new career best although the race did pan out perfectly for him here and he might struggle under a penalty at this level. Nevertheless, while he probably lacks the scope of the runner up, he put in an honest performance and his better conditions and tactics are now more apparent. 105
Bourbali has a fantastic pedigree for the game and was only just denied a winning debut at the post. He looked calm and well beforehand and he travelled as well as anything from the outset. His jumping was fairly novicey in the early stages and was not entirely fluent at the final two flights. There was nothing alarming about his jumping and he put in some very good leaps in the middle of the race so while there is room for improvement, he already has a decent foundation. Bourbali looked the likeliest winner from some way out and traded as low as 1.08 in running. Much the best of those who raced prominently, he did not lack for willingness in the closing stages and ran straight and true up to the line. It was only really inexperience that cost him the race and he can emerge a fair deal better than this level. This was a most promising debut effort. 105
Treaty Of Dingle was another making her hurdling debut and put in a creditable performance first time. Following three successive seconds, she was claimed out of a Lingfield claimer at long odds-on. With her sex allowance taken into account, she came into the race with the highest flat rating. She was slightly keen early on but apart from a slightly awkward jump at the fourth, put in a decent round and kept on well enough to the line. While she did not quite match her flat standard here, she should be able to reach a similar level over jumps in due course. 92
Calidus Mirabilis had shown enough to suggest he can win a race of this nature during his first two runs in Ireland for Joseph O'Brien. However, his endurance is suspect which made the tactics employed today all the more baffling. Racing prominently is often advantageous in juvenile hurdles although to do so in an aggressive fashion requires completely assured stamina. He was still in the lead right up to the penultimate flight but was headed immediately afterwards and was beaten by over twelve lengths without being eased. Calidus Mirabilis is an adequate jumper but does lack fluency and as in previous outings, his hurdling did deteriorate once his tank began to empty. This outing was less a regression than a misuse of tactics as there was still evidence of his relative capabilities. He does need an easy test to show his best however and he may continue to disappoint in the absence of optimal conditions. 92
Prince Percy made a fair impression on his hurdling debut at Market Rasen back in July but had disappointed in the interim on the flat. He was backed into favouritism here but was pulled up between the final two flights which would make this the fifth time in his latest six starts that he has been unable to justify market support. He was keen early on and while he jumped well on his debut, was slightly slow at the third and got in close to the fifth and sixth before jumping his last flight slowly. He is obviously thought capable of better than this and there is a level over hurdles where he can be competitive. However, his current disposition does not inspire faith and while his being cast in his box during the summer was probably not too damaging, a session on a horse sized psychiatrist's couch might be helpful. 80
Lightning Bug's starting price of 150/1 was a fair reflection of her chances and while she managed to beat the other outsiders, she was a good dozen lengths off the leading quintet when coming to grief three from home. It was not a blunder that caused her demise, rather she crumpled on landing after the flight had been negotiated. While slightly awkward at a couple of her other jumps, it was not the worst round for a newcomer but she still has plenty to prove going forward. 0
Brown Eyed Girl's official flat rating of 51 looked steep for what she had actually achieved but she was bred to be better over hurdles and her trainer has a good record in this race. However, Brown Eyed Girl was keen early on but was already being ridden with a circuit left to run and would tail off before being pulled up three out. She may do better if she learns to settle and her jumping was fine apart from a slow jump at the first but there is nothing immediately promising about her future prospects. 0
Full Secret had shown a modicum of ability on the flat for Richard Fahey and was another representing a trainer whose charges have outran their odds in this race. However, she was even further detached from further out than Brown Eyed Girl and safe jumping aside, offered little encouragement. 0
LISTOWEL
Preview review
Longclaw was expected to win more comfortably than he did but while Scholastic hit 1.02 in running, she was never in front for any more than half a stride. Scholastic jumped considerably better than she had on her previous two starts which enabled her to close the margin between herself and the winner. At War's jumping was decent enough for him to outrun his odds while Little Brother was a little too headstrong to do himself justice. Made In Pimlico's effort was not expected but his trainer does get winners in the division and with him quickly pulling up halfway through his sole start this year, he was somewhat unexposed.
Race review
Today's race at Listowel lost a great deal of its interest when Duffle Coat was withdrawn this morning after reportedly being found sore. Nevertheless, it ended up being more competitive than originally anticipated. A pair of keen and free running horses ensured a solid tempo although the winning time was slowest by standard on the card as well as being slower than any of the previous renewals ran on similar ground. The standard of jumping was generally decent, especially by the first two home, and although the loose horse briefly involved herself in the back straight, there were no real hard luck stories. The first three home give the form a decent endorsement but it is diminished by the proximity of the 125/1 shot Made In Pimlico. In all, the race was a decent quality for the time of year but it looks unlikely to have a great influence on the season's better races.
Longclaw made it three from three and was made to battle for the first time in his hurdling career. He posted his best round of jumping to date and though he lost some momentum after getting in close to the last, was able to rally and fend off his persistent challenger. While the runner-up got very close to him, she was in receipt of seventeen pounds and her jumping had massively improved since her last appearance. The form is still as good as anything he has produced thus far and his demonstration of battling qualities entitles this performance to stand marginally as his best to date. With the exception of stablemate Duffle Coat, he stands nine pounds clear of the rest of Ireland's juveniles for the time being. However, he appears to be reaching the limits of his potential and unless the better types are slow to emerge, he may struggle once he forced to step up in class. 126
Scholastic is no better on the flat than her official mark of 70 at this juncture and her jumping left plenty to be desired coming into this race. However, apart from being slightly slow over the second, there was a considerable improvement in her hurdling here and she was on occasion very slick. She also displayed a good attitude in running to the line and was held by only a narrow margin. On this evidence, she is more than capable of winning a small race and her newfound zest for hurdling may provoke further improvement. Notwithstanding, she was still receiving plenty of weight from the winner and her form is still a long way from pattern class so her aspirations can only be limited for the time being. 109
At War is officially rated 75 on the flat but his recent efforts have not reflected that mark. He did not run to that level on his hurdling debut at Punchestown either but his jumping was good there and he replicated his proficiency again this afternoon. He was keen early and was running freely when extending his lead as he embarked on the second circuit. Nevertheless, his jumping was always slick and his first slight error came after he was impeded by the loose horse approaching the sixth. He was headed soon after but was still able to keep tabs on the leaders and it was only on entering the straight that the first two pulled clear of him. He will need to learn how to settle but he has the engine and the hurdling ability to be a problem at this standard. 105
Made In Pimlico had no right to be involved in the race based on his previous flat form and he got in close to several of his hurdles along the way here. He was pulled up quickly half way through his debut at Tipperary after apparently being hampered so was arguably unexposed in that regard. His trainer also managed two winners from three juvenile hurdlers last season which is an improvement on what he had achieved previously. Furthermore, Made In Pimlico was trying cheekpieces for the first time along with his tongue-tie which is another possible factor in his dramatic improvement. Strictly on this outing, he is capable of being competitive in moderate company but he would perhaps first need to demonstrate that this was not a fluke. 104
Little Brother was the other winner in the field but he had disappointed on his return to the flat and he did not quite match the form of his Bellewstown win here. Despite being a winner over hurdles, he has not been the best jumper and there were a few flights here where he was not entirely fluent. That he was rather headstrong did not help him either despite the reapplication of the cheekpieces he wore when winning on his penultimate start. Nevertheless, the form he has shown today is not too far off his best so there is no reason to suspect any severe regression and he would still be respected in lesser company. 108
Finsceal Blue was one of two racecourse debutants in the field but while his sire has a fair record in the division, he did not have the most compelling profile beforehand. Always towards the rear of the field, his jumping was not especially fluent in the early stages and he began to get detached before the field reached the back straight. It would not be difficult for him to improve on this effort but there was little immediate promise. 49
Social Distancing was the other racecourse debutant and her pedigree suggested that she would be neither sharp nor forward enough for this test. She jumped slowly and was detached early on in the race. She was completely tailed off when she fell at the last and there is nothing encouraging to be drawn from this performance. 0
Waterville Lady represented a trainer with a decent record in this race but she was not especially well supported in the market. She jumped to her right and unseated her rider at the second and was fairly wild when jumping loose over the next. 0
Comment