There was a delay to the whole catching up with the reviews thing as my precarious situation saw the caravan becoming unavailable and necessitated a temporary move to Newcastle where a friend has a few weeks remaining on a tenancy for an empty flat. This is actually quite fortuitous as while I will be unable to indulge myself in the awesomeness that is Geordieland, I do have a toilet if nothing else. I will also be able to order the LUCKY 9 VEGAN MEGA BOX. Basically, it is a pizza box filled with mini spring rolls, chips, deep fried tofu and Japanese vegetable gyoza with salt and pepper chilli. It is the greasiest, saltiest box of pure filth to ever insult the planet. But I love it so much that I get irrationally angry just thinking about it and the thought of knocking a year off my life by gorging on same makes me more excited than any other sensual experience known to humanity. But there is still work to be caught up on so I will exercise monastic levels of temperance by foregoing the LUCKY 9 VEGAN MEGA BOX until all reviews are up to date. There are seventy-two performances reviewed in this current batch which leaves fifty-two outstanding. Hopefully these can be finished by Boxing Day eve eve so the previews for the festive races can be done in time.
If I have missed anything prior to the 12th of December then please let me know.
LIMERICK 1st December
Preview review
No preview was written due to circumstances. Crassus had upwards of thirty pounds in hand over his rivals with hurdling experience and while a couple of the newcomers brought flat ratings in the eighties, they each had elements detrimental to their profiles. Palm Beach is an entire and while Galileo and Joseph O'Brien have solid records in the sphere, they do underachieve somewhat when accounting for the quality of flat recruits. Zoffanien's trainer gets winning juveniles but the strike rate is a low one.
Race review
While Limerick sometimes attracts respectable sorts, this was only the second pre-Christmas juvenile held at since 2006 so there would be little to gauge from race trends. Nevertheless, the winner had posted respectable efforts in defeat and there were two newcomers rated above 80. That these three would finish clear of the remainder bodes well for the form. The pace was fairly steady which is understandable in the conditions, but it was not ran at a dawdle as the winning time was quicker than that posted in the concluding bumper.
Crassus had failed to win in twelve outings prior to this contest, but had posted respectable efforts over hurdles behind Duffle Coat and Glorious Zoff, and was in the process of running a big race when falling at Ballinrobe on his penultimate outing. That fall appeared to affect his confidence as his jumping was less assured last time out. However, the clear round had a positive effect as his jumping was as fluent as ever and he made no discernible errors. Crassus led or disputed from the outset and though he was almost joined on the run to the penultimate flight, he never looked in any real trouble and was able to assert his superiority to the tune of just over a length. He wandered a little on the run-in and did not respond delightfully to the whip so while he was able to dispatch of these rivals, he may not fare well in a battle against rivals of equal ability on a given day. Nevertheless, this was a deserved success and would probably mark a new career best. Though unlikely to trouble the best in the division, there are other races for him to win. 126
Palm Beach is the second ex-Ballydoyle runner for the yard this season. Though holding a Derby entry after the first scratchings deadline, Palm Beach did not make the racecourse until September when fourth at Tipperary. He got off the mark later that month in a heavy ground, twelve furlong maiden at Listowel. The second won a maiden next time while the third subsequently took a listed hurdle, with the trio over seven lengths clear of the remainder. A brother to St Leger third Southern France, out of a half-sister to Prix de Diane runner-up Abbatiale, Palm Beach is bred in a manner befitting his Derby entry. Nevertheless, the pedigree is not bereft of useful jumpers as the damline features the likes of Flash Ball (3/1), Amant Gris (3/2) and Triumph Hurdle third Boarding School (4/2). Although he drifted from 8/13, Palm Beach still started a shade of odds-on to make a winning hurdling debut and traded as low as 1.3 to do so. However, he was not helped by some novicey jumping as he got in close to several of his hurdles as well as steadying into the fourth. He was green in the closing stages, but this was due to his inexperience rather than any obvious recalcitrance and was simply beaten by a horse with a better idea about the game. Palm Beach emerges with plenty of credit and has the size and scope to develop into a useful type in due course. 124
Zoffanien was available at 16/1 in the morning, but went off at 6/1. While this movement has the hallmarks of a plunge, there was no reason to be as large as he was as his flat form and pedigree afforded him credible prospects. He won two of his starts for Yan Durepaire, including a 2300 metre good ground Dax handicap off an equivalent mark of 77 back in July. Two of Yan Durepaire's four exports to the division have been winners and Zoffanien, after fetching €60,000 at the Arqana Deauville Summer Sale, is the most expensive. He is also the most expensive purchase in the division for a trainer who gets winners but has a poor strike rate. After getting in close to the first, Zoffanien was ridden into the second with satisfactory results and from there, he posted a nice round of jumping for a newcomer. Initially held up in midfield, he joined the leaders with three furlongs to race and although he never posed a severe threat on the front pair, he beaten to second by less than three lengths and was nineteen lengths clear of the third. He was fairly keen early on which is fair given his layoff and it did not take too long for him to settle. This was a nice introduction to the discipline and he is capable of winning an ordinary contest. 121
The Truant raced nine times on the flat for Jessica Harrington, placing once in a Dundalk maiden over an extended ten furlongs back in February. Though initially rated 72, his mark dropped to 66 after three lesser handicap runs and his last run on the flat came the middle of July. He since left Jessica Harrington to join a yard which is less prolific in the division. Nevertheless, his being by Mastercraftsman is a big positive in the sphere. Held up in the opening stages, The Truant got in close to the first and third flights. Nevertheless, he jumped cleanly thereafter and was able to progress along the back without getting quite close enough to challenge. While lacking the class of the front three, it was not a debut without promise and there appears to be little reason why he can not do as well over hurdles as he had done on the flat. 112
Saga Malta lacked fluency on her debut and fell at the third on her second appearance. Apart from being untidy at the first two, she put in a fair round and though beaten twenty-six lengths, put up a career best effort here. She has yet to show herself capable of winning an ordinary contest and will have better chances in handicap company. 92
Flylikeaneagle quartered in price from an 100/1 available in the morning but was unable to justify the support. He was slow at the first and got in close to the fourth but was otherwise a reasonable jumper. This was no better or worse than his Fairyhouse seventh from the previous month and he would have to improve before being of interest in ordinary company. 89
Sweet Will had been well beaten on his first two starts over hurdles and it was the same story here. His jumping was acceptable safe for a couple of untidy leaps but he is another who failed to progress from the same Fairyhouse contest. 88
Willywampus began his season with a rating of 80 but had ran nowhere near to that mark in a pair of races during June. He was keen early and led briefly passing the stands before fading with half a mile left to run. His jumping was fine and he might strip fitter for the outing. 80
Southwood came into the race following a career best effort on the flat when fourth in a seven furlong handicap at the Curragh. That was off just 45 there is little reason on breeding to suspect significant improvement for the introduction of hurdles. Save for some untidy hurdling in the back, he did not jump too poorly and was still in fifth entering the straight. However, through lack of class and stamina, he had little left to offer. 67
Dazzling Darren put a lot of air between himself and the third hurdle, but otherwise posted a characteristically clear round. However, disappointment is becoming another characteristic as this made it three successive races where he finished tailed off. 73
French Asset beat only one home on a hurdles debut at in October marked by greenness. He once again lacked fluency and finished tailed off here. He has not come remotely close to matching the best of his flat ability thus far. 0
MARKET RASEN 3rd December
Preview review
The race was seen as one where the bulk of the field had questions to answer, and few had solid chances. As such, the relative prospects of the participants were assigned with little confidence. The strong prospect had actually bled on its previous outing although this was mitigated by a month lay-off and despite finishing seventh, was not far from its best here. The winner was given reasonable prospects and trepidation was based on the jumping errors in previous races potentially diminishing the chances afforded by her flat superiority. The remainder of the field over and underperformed to varying degrees but as the first eight were covered by less than twenty lengths, it was not a race which could be definitively assessed to a satisfactory standard.
Race review
While the standard of form was not abysmal, none of these brought solid profiles and the most accomplished had questions to answer. The first three were covered by just over five lengths and the first eight by just under nineteen which is considerably the tightest on a card where the field finished strung out in every other race. The pace was fine and the winning time was comparable with the Class 4 handicap an hour later. The field jumped reasonably and finished in a justifiable order, although they could have finished in any order and it would have been justifiable. The winner is likely the best horse in the race but the form does not look trustworthy.
Volkovka started favourite to win her UK/hurdling debut at Fakenham in late October, but poor jumping and a tendency to hang preceded her pulling up. She was in contention to finish third next time at Leicester in a first time hood, but a bad blunder at the last saw her finish fifth. The best of her flat form gave her a strong chance in this week race and she was able to take advantage with her best round of jumping to date. She got in slightly close to the penultimate flight but this did not cost her any momentum. Held up for much of the contest, she made headway on the long turn for home and was not hard ridden to run out a rather comfortable winner after getting a clear run a furlong from home. The standard of this form is nothing special, but she had the strongest form in the line up and having won a shade cosily, can improve further from here. 99
Shalott did not make the racecourse for Joseph O'Brien, and would start his career in junior bumpers. It is not a sphere which habitually produces successful juvenile hurdlers, particularly not first-time-out. Nevertheless, Shalott had achieved reasonable form in two outings, including a two-length third on his latest start. Being by Camelot and related to numerous winning jumpers, Shalott has a reasonable pedigree for his new vocation and he was not disgraced on his debut. Tracking the leaders, he jumped well for a debutant and moved into the lead at the penultimate flight. His first error came at an untimely moment as he steadied going into the last and was unable to get high at the flight. Though this did cost him momentum, he was back into his stride with a furlong left to run and was beaten by the winner on merit. While he would need to improve to be competitive in anything but a poor race, this was a fine introduction overall. 105
Yulong Magicreef followed a compelling racecourse debut at the Curragh in June with four increasingly disappointing efforts for Jessica Harrington and was beaten fifty lengths on his hurdling debut at Wetherby. There was little cause for complaint insofar as his jumping was concerned and he put up another good round here. Held up in midfield, he joined the vanguard in the straight, but was unable to put his stamp on the race and was outpaced after the last. While a huge improvement on his debut, it was not the most substantial contest and the performance was still someway short of his better flat form. 101
Asharann was a winner in France for Jean-Clause Rouget, but his inability to settle saw his mark drop two and a half kilos and was a factor in two tailed off efforts in the UK. His jumping has always been reasonable however and apart from a blunder at the fifth, put in another clear round here. He still took a keen grip in the early stages, but this was the best he had settled to date and while he never threatened the leaders, he was able to plug on for fourth past beaten horses, finishing just over seven lengths behind the winner. His allotted mark of 104 is harsh based on what he has achieved thus far over hurdles. Nevertheless, it might not be completely beyond his scope if he learns to settle better. 99
Shentri won twice over jumps in France, but was beaten out of sight by Nassalam on his UK debut at Fontwell. He jumped alright here and after racing prominently, was still in contention approaching the last. However, he would fade shortly afterwards and lost fourth on the run-in. He has been dropped eleven pounds after just two starts for Dan Skelton and given that this was an improvement on his Fontwell performance, he would not be in terminal decline. The way he faded and the fact that he was wearing a tongue-tie could be indicative of breathing issues. Nevertheless, his French form is not completely hollow and if the possible issues are resolved, or he simply acclimatises to his new surroundings, he can leave this form behind. 96
Fiscal Prudence had shown some promise in a pair of flat outings for Jim Bolger last year, but pulled too hard on his return at Warwick and was beaten a long way from home. He did not settle much better here but was still in contention turning for home before his exertions took their toll in the straight. He is not without ability, but the first-time hood did not have a sufficient effect on his exuberance and does not make a huge amount of appeal for the time being. 89
Park Lane Dancer did not have the strongest form coming into the race, but looked a reasonably safe conveyance insofar as his jumping and travelling were concerned. However, he put up his poorest round of jumping to date having steadied into the third and sixth while being untidy at the fourth and fifth. He was outclassed by his rivals and while his allotted mark of 93 is low, it is not obviously generous. 89
Sure I'm Your Man made a promising hurdling debut at Bangor, but ran no sort of race just days before this contest at Leicester where he bled through the nose. He was not unfancied in the market, but he never left the rear of the field, was close into the first and was well beaten when untidy over the last. A break might see him run to better effect, but he will clearly have questions to answer on his return. 87
Carriesmatic was third on her final flat outing at Redcar, but that came in a moderate claimer and her official rating of 47 is a fair reflection of her abilities. Nevertheless, she received some each-way support prior to the off but lacked fluency and ultimately finished tailed off. 64
If I have missed anything prior to the 12th of December then please let me know.
LIMERICK 1st December
Preview review
No preview was written due to circumstances. Crassus had upwards of thirty pounds in hand over his rivals with hurdling experience and while a couple of the newcomers brought flat ratings in the eighties, they each had elements detrimental to their profiles. Palm Beach is an entire and while Galileo and Joseph O'Brien have solid records in the sphere, they do underachieve somewhat when accounting for the quality of flat recruits. Zoffanien's trainer gets winning juveniles but the strike rate is a low one.
Race review
While Limerick sometimes attracts respectable sorts, this was only the second pre-Christmas juvenile held at since 2006 so there would be little to gauge from race trends. Nevertheless, the winner had posted respectable efforts in defeat and there were two newcomers rated above 80. That these three would finish clear of the remainder bodes well for the form. The pace was fairly steady which is understandable in the conditions, but it was not ran at a dawdle as the winning time was quicker than that posted in the concluding bumper.
Crassus had failed to win in twelve outings prior to this contest, but had posted respectable efforts over hurdles behind Duffle Coat and Glorious Zoff, and was in the process of running a big race when falling at Ballinrobe on his penultimate outing. That fall appeared to affect his confidence as his jumping was less assured last time out. However, the clear round had a positive effect as his jumping was as fluent as ever and he made no discernible errors. Crassus led or disputed from the outset and though he was almost joined on the run to the penultimate flight, he never looked in any real trouble and was able to assert his superiority to the tune of just over a length. He wandered a little on the run-in and did not respond delightfully to the whip so while he was able to dispatch of these rivals, he may not fare well in a battle against rivals of equal ability on a given day. Nevertheless, this was a deserved success and would probably mark a new career best. Though unlikely to trouble the best in the division, there are other races for him to win. 126
Palm Beach is the second ex-Ballydoyle runner for the yard this season. Though holding a Derby entry after the first scratchings deadline, Palm Beach did not make the racecourse until September when fourth at Tipperary. He got off the mark later that month in a heavy ground, twelve furlong maiden at Listowel. The second won a maiden next time while the third subsequently took a listed hurdle, with the trio over seven lengths clear of the remainder. A brother to St Leger third Southern France, out of a half-sister to Prix de Diane runner-up Abbatiale, Palm Beach is bred in a manner befitting his Derby entry. Nevertheless, the pedigree is not bereft of useful jumpers as the damline features the likes of Flash Ball (3/1), Amant Gris (3/2) and Triumph Hurdle third Boarding School (4/2). Although he drifted from 8/13, Palm Beach still started a shade of odds-on to make a winning hurdling debut and traded as low as 1.3 to do so. However, he was not helped by some novicey jumping as he got in close to several of his hurdles as well as steadying into the fourth. He was green in the closing stages, but this was due to his inexperience rather than any obvious recalcitrance and was simply beaten by a horse with a better idea about the game. Palm Beach emerges with plenty of credit and has the size and scope to develop into a useful type in due course. 124
Zoffanien was available at 16/1 in the morning, but went off at 6/1. While this movement has the hallmarks of a plunge, there was no reason to be as large as he was as his flat form and pedigree afforded him credible prospects. He won two of his starts for Yan Durepaire, including a 2300 metre good ground Dax handicap off an equivalent mark of 77 back in July. Two of Yan Durepaire's four exports to the division have been winners and Zoffanien, after fetching €60,000 at the Arqana Deauville Summer Sale, is the most expensive. He is also the most expensive purchase in the division for a trainer who gets winners but has a poor strike rate. After getting in close to the first, Zoffanien was ridden into the second with satisfactory results and from there, he posted a nice round of jumping for a newcomer. Initially held up in midfield, he joined the leaders with three furlongs to race and although he never posed a severe threat on the front pair, he beaten to second by less than three lengths and was nineteen lengths clear of the third. He was fairly keen early on which is fair given his layoff and it did not take too long for him to settle. This was a nice introduction to the discipline and he is capable of winning an ordinary contest. 121
The Truant raced nine times on the flat for Jessica Harrington, placing once in a Dundalk maiden over an extended ten furlongs back in February. Though initially rated 72, his mark dropped to 66 after three lesser handicap runs and his last run on the flat came the middle of July. He since left Jessica Harrington to join a yard which is less prolific in the division. Nevertheless, his being by Mastercraftsman is a big positive in the sphere. Held up in the opening stages, The Truant got in close to the first and third flights. Nevertheless, he jumped cleanly thereafter and was able to progress along the back without getting quite close enough to challenge. While lacking the class of the front three, it was not a debut without promise and there appears to be little reason why he can not do as well over hurdles as he had done on the flat. 112
Saga Malta lacked fluency on her debut and fell at the third on her second appearance. Apart from being untidy at the first two, she put in a fair round and though beaten twenty-six lengths, put up a career best effort here. She has yet to show herself capable of winning an ordinary contest and will have better chances in handicap company. 92
Flylikeaneagle quartered in price from an 100/1 available in the morning but was unable to justify the support. He was slow at the first and got in close to the fourth but was otherwise a reasonable jumper. This was no better or worse than his Fairyhouse seventh from the previous month and he would have to improve before being of interest in ordinary company. 89
Sweet Will had been well beaten on his first two starts over hurdles and it was the same story here. His jumping was acceptable safe for a couple of untidy leaps but he is another who failed to progress from the same Fairyhouse contest. 88
Willywampus began his season with a rating of 80 but had ran nowhere near to that mark in a pair of races during June. He was keen early and led briefly passing the stands before fading with half a mile left to run. His jumping was fine and he might strip fitter for the outing. 80
Southwood came into the race following a career best effort on the flat when fourth in a seven furlong handicap at the Curragh. That was off just 45 there is little reason on breeding to suspect significant improvement for the introduction of hurdles. Save for some untidy hurdling in the back, he did not jump too poorly and was still in fifth entering the straight. However, through lack of class and stamina, he had little left to offer. 67
Dazzling Darren put a lot of air between himself and the third hurdle, but otherwise posted a characteristically clear round. However, disappointment is becoming another characteristic as this made it three successive races where he finished tailed off. 73
French Asset beat only one home on a hurdles debut at in October marked by greenness. He once again lacked fluency and finished tailed off here. He has not come remotely close to matching the best of his flat ability thus far. 0
MARKET RASEN 3rd December
Preview review
The race was seen as one where the bulk of the field had questions to answer, and few had solid chances. As such, the relative prospects of the participants were assigned with little confidence. The strong prospect had actually bled on its previous outing although this was mitigated by a month lay-off and despite finishing seventh, was not far from its best here. The winner was given reasonable prospects and trepidation was based on the jumping errors in previous races potentially diminishing the chances afforded by her flat superiority. The remainder of the field over and underperformed to varying degrees but as the first eight were covered by less than twenty lengths, it was not a race which could be definitively assessed to a satisfactory standard.
Race review
While the standard of form was not abysmal, none of these brought solid profiles and the most accomplished had questions to answer. The first three were covered by just over five lengths and the first eight by just under nineteen which is considerably the tightest on a card where the field finished strung out in every other race. The pace was fine and the winning time was comparable with the Class 4 handicap an hour later. The field jumped reasonably and finished in a justifiable order, although they could have finished in any order and it would have been justifiable. The winner is likely the best horse in the race but the form does not look trustworthy.
Volkovka started favourite to win her UK/hurdling debut at Fakenham in late October, but poor jumping and a tendency to hang preceded her pulling up. She was in contention to finish third next time at Leicester in a first time hood, but a bad blunder at the last saw her finish fifth. The best of her flat form gave her a strong chance in this week race and she was able to take advantage with her best round of jumping to date. She got in slightly close to the penultimate flight but this did not cost her any momentum. Held up for much of the contest, she made headway on the long turn for home and was not hard ridden to run out a rather comfortable winner after getting a clear run a furlong from home. The standard of this form is nothing special, but she had the strongest form in the line up and having won a shade cosily, can improve further from here. 99
Shalott did not make the racecourse for Joseph O'Brien, and would start his career in junior bumpers. It is not a sphere which habitually produces successful juvenile hurdlers, particularly not first-time-out. Nevertheless, Shalott had achieved reasonable form in two outings, including a two-length third on his latest start. Being by Camelot and related to numerous winning jumpers, Shalott has a reasonable pedigree for his new vocation and he was not disgraced on his debut. Tracking the leaders, he jumped well for a debutant and moved into the lead at the penultimate flight. His first error came at an untimely moment as he steadied going into the last and was unable to get high at the flight. Though this did cost him momentum, he was back into his stride with a furlong left to run and was beaten by the winner on merit. While he would need to improve to be competitive in anything but a poor race, this was a fine introduction overall. 105
Yulong Magicreef followed a compelling racecourse debut at the Curragh in June with four increasingly disappointing efforts for Jessica Harrington and was beaten fifty lengths on his hurdling debut at Wetherby. There was little cause for complaint insofar as his jumping was concerned and he put up another good round here. Held up in midfield, he joined the vanguard in the straight, but was unable to put his stamp on the race and was outpaced after the last. While a huge improvement on his debut, it was not the most substantial contest and the performance was still someway short of his better flat form. 101
Asharann was a winner in France for Jean-Clause Rouget, but his inability to settle saw his mark drop two and a half kilos and was a factor in two tailed off efforts in the UK. His jumping has always been reasonable however and apart from a blunder at the fifth, put in another clear round here. He still took a keen grip in the early stages, but this was the best he had settled to date and while he never threatened the leaders, he was able to plug on for fourth past beaten horses, finishing just over seven lengths behind the winner. His allotted mark of 104 is harsh based on what he has achieved thus far over hurdles. Nevertheless, it might not be completely beyond his scope if he learns to settle better. 99
Shentri won twice over jumps in France, but was beaten out of sight by Nassalam on his UK debut at Fontwell. He jumped alright here and after racing prominently, was still in contention approaching the last. However, he would fade shortly afterwards and lost fourth on the run-in. He has been dropped eleven pounds after just two starts for Dan Skelton and given that this was an improvement on his Fontwell performance, he would not be in terminal decline. The way he faded and the fact that he was wearing a tongue-tie could be indicative of breathing issues. Nevertheless, his French form is not completely hollow and if the possible issues are resolved, or he simply acclimatises to his new surroundings, he can leave this form behind. 96
Fiscal Prudence had shown some promise in a pair of flat outings for Jim Bolger last year, but pulled too hard on his return at Warwick and was beaten a long way from home. He did not settle much better here but was still in contention turning for home before his exertions took their toll in the straight. He is not without ability, but the first-time hood did not have a sufficient effect on his exuberance and does not make a huge amount of appeal for the time being. 89
Park Lane Dancer did not have the strongest form coming into the race, but looked a reasonably safe conveyance insofar as his jumping and travelling were concerned. However, he put up his poorest round of jumping to date having steadied into the third and sixth while being untidy at the fourth and fifth. He was outclassed by his rivals and while his allotted mark of 93 is low, it is not obviously generous. 89
Sure I'm Your Man made a promising hurdling debut at Bangor, but ran no sort of race just days before this contest at Leicester where he bled through the nose. He was not unfancied in the market, but he never left the rear of the field, was close into the first and was well beaten when untidy over the last. A break might see him run to better effect, but he will clearly have questions to answer on his return. 87
Carriesmatic was third on her final flat outing at Redcar, but that came in a moderate claimer and her official rating of 47 is a fair reflection of her abilities. Nevertheless, she received some each-way support prior to the off but lacked fluency and ultimately finished tailed off. 64
Comment