Announcement

Collapse

Fat Jockey Patrons

Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated.
Become a Patron!

You can also make a one-off donation here:
See more
See less

2024 Triumph Hurdle (Juveniles)

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Brian said a horse for next year. Confident nod. (Salvator Mundi) post race interview

    Comment


    • Originally posted by Exar Essay View Post
      I must say I'd not be put off by that at all. Travelled well enough and he's finished 2 lengths behind Storm Heart, 3 lengths behind Nurburgring and 3 lengths ahead of Bunting. I think the front 2 are very good and the 3rd has run some race too, making most of it. Willie has literally just said in his post race interview that all of his are coming on for the run this season also.
      Exactly this, look what the winner just did haha!

      Comment


      • Just rewatched this. Majborough found plenty in what looked a well run race in those conditions.

        Racing Post with a provisional RPR of 144 which is the lowest rating for the last 10 years when factoring in the sex allowance. They currently have the front 3 last year all ahead of Majborough and Kargese. That contrasts to Simon Rowlands who has it joint 2nd highest since 2009.

        He's got so much potential and hopefully they put him over fences next season and up in trip - I can see him lining up in that Limerick race at Xmas and I don't see many I'd fancy up against him in the likely conditions.

        Ruby and Willie seem to love him as well.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by DenmanSacre View Post
          Just rewatched this. Majborough found plenty in what looked a well run race in those conditions.

          Racing Post with a provisional RPR of 144 which is the lowest rating for the last 10 years when factoring in the sex allowance. They currently have the front 3 last year all ahead of Majborough and Kargese. That contrasts to Simon Rowlands who has it joint 2nd highest since 2009.

          He's got so much potential and hopefully they put him over fences next season and up in trip - I can see him lining up in that Limerick race at Xmas and I don't see many I'd fancy up against him in the likely conditions.

          Ruby and Willie seem to love him as well.
          I’ve said it a few times but I really think Sir G, Maj and Kalif Du Berlais are going to be golden age of chasers in the next few years.

          Comment


          • Originally posted by JackieMoon33 View Post

            I’ve said it a few times but I really think Sir G, Maj and Kalif Du Berlais are going to be golden age of chasers in the next few years.
            As Sir G has been mentioned (still sore) Where's his future now? Aintree then Fences next season?

            Comment


            • I’d imagine that they’d go slowly with SG and stay over hurdles next season. Novice chasing as 5/6 yo
              either way looking forward to seeing him fit and well again

              Comment


              • Originally posted by CJW View Post

                As Sir G has been mentioned (still sore) Where's his future now? Aintree then Fences next season?
                I’m not sure they’ll all go chasing next season to be honest and it wouldn’t surprise me if one of them are held back a year and given a 5yo campaign over hurdles. Nicholls sent Clan and Frodon straight novice chasing so I’d imagine Kalif Du Berlais would follow suit.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Guinness Village View Post
                  I’d imagine that they’d go slowly with SG and stay over hurdles next season. Novice chasing as 5/6 yo
                  either way looking forward to seeing him fit and well again
                  I'd say this will sadly be true. Henderson wasting a year of his career unless he takes him to France to win the 4 year old grade 1s that are there for the taking. Henderson has zero imagination though so we'll see him winning some crap grade 2s or 3s in England before being smashed in the Champion Hurdle. The Arkle is there for the taking next year.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by DenmanSacre View Post

                    I'd say this will sadly be true. Henderson wasting a year of his career unless he takes him to France to win the 4 year old grade 1s that are there for the taking. Henderson has zero imagination though so we'll see him winning some crap grade 2s or 3s in England before being smashed in the Champion Hurdle. The Arkle is there for the taking next year.
                    How many 4 year olds thrive in open company?

                    He's seen a race track 3 times, even Defi who raced 6 tjmes
                    struggled his 5 year old season. I think more will follow Mullins plan with Lossie and have a quiet season and I think long term for the horse it's the best thing. Even Espoir D'allen when he won the CH only really raced against horses his own age in his second season before his CH win.

                    Novice hurdlers seem to be trending towards being 6 at the festival not 5 so you're putting him in against horses that are 2 years further down their development even in a beginners chase (for example). And I would disagree that the Arkle is wide open, it's more than reasonable to expect to see Slade Steel there and his form is as solid as they come.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Hurricane fly View Post

                      How many 4 year olds thrive in open company?

                      He's seen a race track 3 times, even Defi who raced 6 tjmes
                      struggled his 5 year old season. I think more will follow Mullins plan with Lossie and have a quiet season and I think long term for the horse it's the best thing. Even Espoir D'allen when he won the CH only really raced against horses his own age in his second season before his CH win.

                      Novice hurdlers seem to be trending towards being 6 at the festival not 5 so you're putting him in against horses that are 2 years further down their development even in a beginners chase (for example). And I would disagree that the Arkle is wide open, it's more than reasonable to expect to see Slade Steel there and his form is as solid as they come.
                      Totally agree. It’s only 2 runs ago his jumping was very poor. He has a great engine but his body hasn’t caught up with him yet. Bring him on slowly and let his body grow into his frame.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Hurricane fly View Post

                        How many 4 year olds thrive in open company?

                        He's seen a race track 3 times, even Defi who raced 6 tjmes
                        struggled his 5 year old season. I think more will follow Mullins plan with Lossie and have a quiet season and I think long term for the horse it's the best thing. Even Espoir D'allen when he won the CH only really raced against horses his own age in his second season before his CH win.

                        Novice hurdlers seem to be trending towards being 6 at the festival not 5 so you're putting him in against horses that are 2 years further down their development even in a beginners chase (for example). And I would disagree that the Arkle is wide open, it's more than reasonable to expect to see Slade Steel there and his form is as solid as they come.
                        I think the quiet season is a load of rubbish for the French bred horses. Mullins only gave Lossiemouth a reduced season as he wanted to keep her, State Man and IEP away from each other early on. Her not running in November/December hasn't enabled her to win the Mares Hurdle. She's just a very smart mare and ahead of that class of mares.

                        ​​​​​​Lossiemouth ran 6 times as a juvenile hurdler. If she needs a quiet 4 to 5 year old season to mature, why did he run her so much as a 3/4 year old. Surely it's contradictory that you can run so much in that season but then need a quiet season to mature.

                        Slade Steel is a below par Supreme winner - if Henry says SS is being aimed at the Arkle, that won't have any impact on any other horse wanting to target the Arkle.

                        The novice hurdles have always trended towards 6 year olds - in the Supreme and Ballymore, there's been 8 6 year old winners in the Ballymore in the last 10 years (1 5 year old and 1 7 year old in the same period winning it) and the Supreme has 6 6 year old winners in the last 10 years (3 5 year olds and 1 7 year old). It usually takes an exceptional 5 year old to win either race - Constitution Hill, Impaire et Passe, Douvan, Klassical Dream. Notably 3 of them are French bred and the other is arguably the best hurdler we have seen.

                        If Sir Gino was a year older and in that Supreme field, I have no doubt he would be more than good enough to beat Slade Steel. He probably would have been good enough this year tbh with the age allowance. If he jumps a fence well, then he's just a better horse than Slade Steel.

                        As for busy 3/4 and 4/5 year old seasons, we have ample evidence for the following French bred horses that it caused no issues:

                        Kauto Star
                        Long Run
                        Master Minded
                        Theleme
                        Hermes Baie
                        De Bon Couer
                        A Plus Tard
                        Klassical Dream
                        Protektorat
                        Frodon
                        Pic D'Orhy
                        L'Autonomie

                        ​​​​​​
                        This thing of not campaigning horses in many races has creeped in over the last few years and it's a massive detriment to the sport. It did none of the old greats any harm running 6 or more times a season. How many top National Hunt horses do we see do that any more.

                        With Sir Gino, he was precocious enough to win a 3 year hurdle in March of his 3 year old season. He could easily be a horse that reaches his peak early and declines earlier. Why waste it when the UK season doesn't reward 4 to 5 year olds staying hurdling. If there was more of a programme for them staying in their age group then I wouldn't have an issue.

                        If he did stay hurdling, I'd like to see him go to Aintree in April, then Auteuil for the grade 1, a prep race in October then the grade 1 at Auteuil in November. Give him a couple of months off, go to the International Hurdle at Cheltenham then the Champion Hurdle. That would be a great campaign. What Henderson will do is take him to the races that Constitution Hill won't run in - races like the Kingwell etc. Naff races in an uninspiring campaign.

                        Comment


                        • I wouldn't disagree with the way that Henderson campaigns horses now is uninspired, but that would remain a wider issue about the racing calendar that allows him to do so.

                          However, I think that the gap between Juveniles and novices/open company is often understated. I don't think it's any different to humans stepping up from youth to adult sports, it typically takes time to adapt and catch up.

                          It's not that great a comparison but Lossie winning the International was 2 seconds quicker than Sir Ginos last win on the same day. They both won very easy on the bridle, but that equates to 10 lengths, and she would have a further 2lb pull at the weights as he will need to step up to carrying max weight and give away 7lbs not 5lb.

                          So before we even get to the boy superstars he has 12 lengths to find and that's before we know what he actually finds under pressure. I hope we do see him again this year and against some of the Irish horses so we can better ascertain his real level.


                          Our Conor routed the field at Cheltenham and was competitive the season after but currently all we know is that SG is significantly better than the English but who isn't? If you took the Irish out of the race then Salver just won the Triumph by 30 lengths. Milan Tino didn't live up to expectation in the Boodles which would have strengthen SGs form significantly.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by DenmanSacre View Post

                            If Sir Gino was a year older and in that Supreme field, I have no doubt he would be more than good enough to beat Slade Steel. He probably would have been good enough this year tbh with the age allowance. If he jumps a fence well, then he's just a better horse than Slade Steel.
                            On what evidence is this based?

                            A beating of Burdett Road & Royal Way ?

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Hurricane fly View Post
                              I wouldn't disagree with the way that Henderson campaigns horses now is uninspired, but that would remain a wider issue about the racing calendar that allows him to do so.

                              However, I think that the gap between Juveniles and novices/open company is often understated. I don't think it's any different to humans stepping up from youth to adult sports, it typically takes time to adapt and catch up.

                              It's not that great a comparison but Lossie winning the International was 2 seconds quicker than Sir Ginos last win on the same day. They both won very easy on the bridle, but that equates to 10 lengths, and she would have a further 2lb pull at the weights as he will need to step up to carrying max weight and give away 7lbs not 5lb.

                              So before we even get to the boy superstars he has 12 lengths to find and that's before we know what he actually finds under pressure. I hope we do see him again this year and against some of the Irish horses so we can better ascertain his real level.


                              Our Conor routed the field at Cheltenham and was competitive the season after but currently all we know is that SG is significantly better than the English but who isn't? If you took the Irish out of the race then Salver just won the Triumph by 30 lengths. Milan Tino didn't live up to expectation in the Boodles which would have strengthen SGs form significantly.
                              Sir Gino had an overall quicker time than Lossiemouth on Trials day according to RP, Sporting life and ATR by nearly 2 seconds? Overall times are pretty meaningless anyway.

                              Our Conor was taking on Hurricane Fly. Sir Gino would be taking on a poor set of novice hurdlers outside of Ballyburn going over fences so it's worlds apart on what they'd be facing in their 4 to 5 year old season. The biggest challenge he would face is Impaire et Passe, who is obviously a very good mid 160s hurdler and could be too much for Sir Gino. But they could feasibly be aimed at different races at Cheltenham over fences anyway.

                              It can be a big step up from the juvenile season to the next season in open age company but there's examples of many horses that have took it in stride. We will have to wait and see how he gets on next season but he's a horse I'll be looking forward to seeing next season while the flat season is on.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by Garrison Savannah View Post

                                On what evidence is this based?

                                A beating of Burdett Road & Royal Way ?
                                Eye test.

                                Ratings.

                                To me, Sir Gino is a very very good juvenile. Slade Steel would be 3rd or worse in most Supremes.

                                Slade Steel doesn't exactly have a great resume of horses beaten.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X