Announcement

Collapse

Fat Jockey Patrons

Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated.
Become a Patron!

You can also make a one-off donation here:
See more
See less

2023 Novice Chasers

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by Green Goddess View Post

    You wonder if they were just waiting for Constitution Hill to run before deciding which route to take
    The closing date for the grade 1 entries over chiasmas in Ireland was last Wednesday.

    I doubt WM will have many runners in the 2m Novice at Leopardstown (grade 1) looking at this years program, Bchase options;

    03/12 FHouse 2M5F
    06/12 Tramore 2M5F
    10/12 Navan 2M4F
    10/12 Navan 2M1F Grade 3
    11/12 Punchestown 2M FH won last year 5th Dec

    Comment


    • Originally posted by darlojim View Post
      Neither El fabiolo or Dysart Dynamo declared, disappointing.

      Tmsg dec'd
      Sort of hoping she doesn't take to fences...... is that wrong of me ?

      Comment


      • Originally posted by Lobos View Post

        Sort of hoping she doesn't take to fences...... is that wrong of me ?
        Get her onside, your use of the word 'hoping' says a lot. They wouldn't be sending her chasing if she wasn't schooling well.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by FredFlintstone View Post

          Get her onside, your use of the word 'hoping' says a lot. They wouldn't be sending her chasing if she wasn't schooling well.
          Just don't fancy a Mare at her age going Chasing. Think they should stick to Hurdles and redemption in the Mares.

          Comment


          • Originally posted by Lobos View Post

            Just don't fancy a Mare at her age going Chasing. Think they should stick to Hurdles and redemption in the Mares.
            She’s only 7 Lobos? Not every mare will go down the breeding sheds.

            Why shouldn’t she have a full career if fitness and health allow it.

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Craigy14 View Post

              She’s only 7 Lobos? Not every mare will go down the breeding sheds.

              Why shouldn’t she have a full career if fitness and health allow it.
              Probably because he may have money on her for the mares hurdle

              Comment


              • Originally posted by FinalFurlong91 View Post

                Probably because he may have money on her for the mares hurdle
                Naughty



                Bang on though. She was the winner before being brought down this year. She deserves a shot at redemption. Think she'd have a big chance too. Can't see that Henry has any other Mare to step up ?

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Lobos View Post

                  Naughty



                  Bang on though. She was the winner before being brought down this year. She deserves a shot at redemption. Think she'd have a big chance too. Can't see that Henry has any other Mare to step up ?
                  Controversially - the honey monster.

                  Would you rather retire as an unbeaten mare with another grade 1 in the bag or as the mare who was beaten by the jumping equivalent of Frankel in her last race? I'd go for the mares hurdle if constitution was unbeatable personally.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by Odin View Post

                    Controversially - the honey monster.

                    Would you rather retire as an unbeaten mare with another grade 1 in the bag or as the mare who was beaten by the jumping equivalent of Frankel in her last race? I'd go for the mares hurdle if constitution was unbeatable personally.
                    Even if CH does look unbeatable, Henry doesn’t strike me as a trainer to duck out of a challenge and fully expect Honeysuckle to go out as a champion should......fighting to the death

                    Unless she’s beaten pre Cheltenham which paints a different picture

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Odin View Post

                      Controversially - the honey monster.

                      Would you rather retire as an unbeaten mare with another grade 1 in the bag or as the mare who was beaten by the jumping equivalent of Frankel in her last race? I'd go for the mares hurdle if constitution was unbeatable personally.
                      By some considerable distance I'd rather go out on my shield in the champion hurdle

                      Imagine declaring for the mares just for constitution hill to have an off day or get a stone bruise

                      It would be a travesty if she doesn't go for 3 in a row

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Odin View Post

                        Controversially - the honey monster.

                        Would you rather retire as an unbeaten mare with another grade 1 in the bag or as the mare who was beaten by the jumping equivalent of Frankel in her last race? I'd go for the mares hurdle if constitution was unbeatable personally.
                        If that happens I don’t see why we bother with national hunt racing!

                        We’ve been crying out for a decent contender to Honeysuckles crown! She’s won the mares why shirk a challenge?! Makes no sense, it would have relatively no bearing on breeding, she’s won 11 grade 1’s could be 13 by time Cheltenham comes round.

                        Comment


                        • I don't wanna derail another thread but the only other horse I've been ok with ducking in my lifetime is Frankel. Not sea the stars, baeed, galopin, altior or allaho. I don't think it's the death of national hunt racing or anything like that if ONE horse every decade is ducked.

                          Fwiw I don't think HDB would do it anyway, but I'm comfortable in my thought process that if I had a chance to retire my mare unbeaten as a four time Cheltenham grade 1 winner across two distances, with 13 grade 1s overall, her legacy wouldn't be at all affected by my decision. Luckily based on the reaction, she's not mine and we can look forward to the race

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by FinalFurlong91 View Post

                            By some considerable distance I'd rather go out on my shield in the champion hurdle

                            Imagine declaring for the mares just for constitution hill to have an off day or get a stone bruise

                            It would be a travesty if she doesn't go for 3 in a row
                            Absolutely this. No way Henry or Honey will duck anything. Whilst I expect CH to win, he'll have to work very, very hard for it. She won't give up without a fight. He looks a superstar but won't get that title until he's won the Champion Hurdle. Any little chink in his armour and she'll exploit it.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Lobos View Post

                              Absolutely this. No way Henry or Honey will duck anything. Whilst I expect CH to win, he'll have to work very, very hard for it. She won't give up without a fight. He looks a superstar but won't get that title until he's won the Champion Hurdle. Any little chink in his armour and she'll exploit it.
                              It won't effect the price of her foals at all either if she has a defeat on her record at all

                              A walk in the park or saint des saints foal out of honeysuckle will be worth a fortune either way. The value of her progeny was secured when she won her first champion hurdle.

                              It's not like she's a prospective sire and a big defeat is any kind of blemish.

                              Comment


                              • I’m sorry but I’m finding all this talk of constitution hill being the the frankel of flat racing and he’ll wipe the floor with honeysuckle etc a bit silly now after one run in open company.

                                i like everyone else was blown away by his run in the fighting fifth and believe he could possibly be very very special but assuming that is the case without doubt on the evidence we have so far is jumping the gun imo. The form of the supreme is still questionable, were they a very good bunch of novices that he beat? Would sir gerhard/state man have thumped Jonbon too? The jury is still out at this point imo. He then goes to Newcastle and destroys Epatante in what was a breathtaking performance, but are we sure that was the same Epatante we’re used to? She looked to travel well but all it would take to raise doubts is something like pied piper coming over and beating her a few lengths and we’d all be thinking “hold on, she looks to have declined, was con hills performance as special as it looked?”

                                For the record I think he is a freak but would like more evidence before being as sure about it as everyone on here seems to be, and talk of him destroying a double champion hurdle winning undefeated mare, and piling barrow loads of cash onto him winning the champion hurdle at odds on because he is a certainty off the back of one run in open company, is very premature imo.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X