Figured we should start having individual threads for most races now? Being October and some nice horses starting to appear...(come on Kev pull your finger out )
And the talk of Your Darling and his subsequent defeat today got me thinking about this race.
Plenty will get talked up, with connections understandably bullish ahead of the new season but this race (along with many to be fair) really does boil down to Mullins, Elliott and Henderson.
In the last 8 seasons the 3 placed horses in each renewal have been trained by:
2020
Shishkin - Henderson
Abacadabras - Elliott
Chantry House - Henderson
2019
Klassical Dream - Mullins
Thomas Darby - O Murphy
Itchy Feet - O Murphy
2018
Summerville Boy - George
Kalashnikov - A Murphy
Mengli Khan - Elliott
2017
Labaik - Elliott
Melon - Mullins
River Wylde - Henderson
2016
Altior - Henderson
Min - Mullins
Buveur D'Air - Henderson
2015
Douvan - Mullins
Shaneshill - Mullins
Sizing John - de Bromhead
2014
Vautour - Mullins
Josses Hill - Henderson
Vaniteux - Henderson
2013
Champagne Fever - Mullins
My Tent Or Yours - Henderson
Jezki - Harrington
75% of the places have been filled by those 3 trainers
With those 3 doing a clean sweep of the placings in 4 of those runnings.
Way ahead of the other 2 main ovice hurdles in that time.
With only 6 of the 24 places going to other trainers.
Despite how highly a horse may be considered, it'll take a very good horse to have me fancying their chances here outside of the big 3 trainers and it really does pay to focus most of the attention on those. Stating the obvious to a degree, they are the 3 best festival trainers, with more often than not more than one chance in the race (less so with Elliott who has so far only once had more than 1 runner)
2020 - Mullins x4 / Elliott x1 / Henderson x3
2019 - Mullins x2 / Elliott x2 / Henderson x2
2018 - Mullins x3 / Elliott x1 / Henderson x1
2017 - Mullins x4 / Elliott x1 / Henderson x2
2016 - Mullins x3 / Elliott x1 / Henderson x2
2015 - Mullins x4 / Henderson x2
2014 - Mullins x3 / Henderson x2
2013 - Mullins x3 / Elliott x1 / Henderson x2
The problem of course is narrowing the horses down from an antepost point of view, and then on the day. When most likely there could be 20-30 horses between the three that start the season as potential Supreme horses. With the 3 averaging a combined 6 runners in the race per year.
That said the market generally has it spot in when it comes to the best horses from each yard.
Over those last 8 years, each of the trainers shortest prices runner has finished ahead of their own stablemate except once - when Josses Hill (14/1) finished ahead of Vaniteux (11/1) in 2014, though even then they both placed. Even if they do not win, the market had it right in who was the yards leading hope in the race.
2020
Henderson - Shishkin - 1st
Elliott - Abacadabras - 2nd
Mullins - Asterion Forlonge - 4th
2019
Henderson - Angels Breath - 7th
Elliott - Felix Desjy - 6th
Mullins - Klassical Dream - 1st
2018
Henderson - Claimintakinforgan - 5th
Elliott - Mengli Khan - 3rd
Mullins - Getabird - 11th
2017
Henderson - River Wylde - 3rd
Elliott - Labaik - 1st
Mullins - Melon - 2nd
2016
Henderson - Altior - 1st
Elliott - Tombstone - 4th
Mullins - Min - 2nd
2015
Henderson - L'ami Serge - 4th
Mullins - Douvan - 1st
2014
Henderson - Vaniteux - 3rd (Josses Hill 2nd)
Mullins - Vautour - 1st
2013
Henderson - My Tent Or Yours - 2nd
Elliott - Cause of Causes - 7th
Mullins - Champagne Fever - 1st
So the story in this race is find the main fancy from each of Mullins, Henderson and Elliott.
Don't spend too much time looking elsewhere...
and you'll do alright
For reference as of 13/10/20 The market has the 3 following horses as the shortest priced for each trainer:
Mullins - Ferny Hollow 10/1
Elliott - Ballyadam 16/1
Henderson - Flinteur Sacre 20/1
Comment