Originally posted by Goldentouch
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
Fat Jockey Patrons
Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated.
Become a Patron!
You can also make a one-off donation here:
Become a Patron!
You can also make a one-off donation here:
See more
See less
MARTIN PIPE Conditionals Handicap Hurdle
Collapse
X
-
-
Originally posted by Spectre View Post
Isn't Top Bandit more likely for the County Hurdle. Two miles on the new course looks like it would suit perfectly. With Chemical Energy also supposedly destined for the Pipe it would seem like a more obvious destination.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Spectre View Post
Isn't Top Bandit more likely for the County Hurdle. Two miles on the new course looks like it would suit perfectly. With Chemical Energy also supposedly destined for the Pipe it would seem like a more obvious destination.
Comment
-
Originally posted by JackieMoon33 View Post
Exactly how I’d see it. Top Bandit not tried over further than 2m which would be against Gordon’s usual MO. Coupled with he travels and finishes off races great over 2m means I can’t see Top Bandit stepping up. He also need to be delivered late which they’ll be able to in a fast paced County.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Lobos View Post
He beat Jetoile into 3rd at Cheltenham as well which now looks really solid form.
From that, I gauge he too could be very useful up in trip, coupled with his breeding.
I couldn't 100% discount the County Hurdle as a target, though I do have another couple of Gordons in mind for that.
For me, I think Top Bandit would be a serious contender for this race though.
As he is under 141 he would still have time to run up in trip once the weights are out and only clobber a 5lb penalty for it, so would still get in.Last edited by ComplyOrDie; 12 January 2022, 01:49 PM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ComplyOrDie View Post
Jetoile went up in trip to win the next twice, as did the 2nd, Brorson, who has also won his next two starts. The form is good, no question about that, but he beat horses over a trip that now looked inadequate for them.
From that, I gauge he too could be very useful up in trip, coupled with his breeding.
I couldn't 100% discount the County Hurdle as a target, though I do have another couple of Gordons in mind for that.
For me, I think Top Bandit would be a serious contender for this race though.
As he is under 141 he would still have time to run up in trip once the weights are out and only clobber a 5lb penalty for it, so would still get in.
I very much doubt they’ll want to take a penalty into the Festival and add anything extra to his mark when he’s already guaranteed to run in any handicap they want.
Comment
-
Originally posted by JackieMoon33 View Post
If you didn’t know his breeding and only watched his races, would you think he needs a step up? The breeding angle is questionable in this case anyway and never conclusive.
I very much doubt they’ll want to take a penalty into the Festival and add anything extra to his mark when he’s already guaranteed to run in any handicap they want.
If he was being primed for the County I'd be wanting a Belfast Banter rating of around 129, for a novice, like him. He's 2lbs higher than Saint Roi when he ran in the race, and on what we've seen (manner of victories) I'd have him in no way close to him. The only way I see enough improvement in him for a festival race is a step up in trip, and the Martin Pipe has that ceiling of 145, so you know the rough level you're aiming at, which is what Gordon is so good at.
As I've said before, I may be way off the mark, but I won't be backing for the County Hurdle, regardless, and will congratulate those that have should he end up winning it
Comment
-
Originally posted by ComplyOrDie View Post
It's kinda irrelevant because we do have his breeding, but if I had to look on form alone he doesn't interest me for the County at all, especially off 139. He's been beating low level horses over 2m, and has a high enough mark for doing so. I've looked at the form, and noted what he has beat and what they've gone on to do, and the majority need or have produced over further. If he's an out and out 2 miler he needs to be having the speed and pace to be beating them further, IMO.
If he was being primed for the County I'd be wanting a Belfast Banter rating of around 129, for a novice, like him. He's 2lbs higher than Saint Roi when he ran in the race, and on what we've seen (manner of victories) I'd have him in no way close to him. The only way I see enough improvement in him for a festival race is a step up in trip, and the Martin Pipe has that ceiling of 145, so you know the rough level you're aiming at, which is what Gordon is so good at.
As I've said before, I may be way off the mark, but I won't be backing for the County Hurdle, regardless, and will congratulate those that have should he end up winning it
Most years you need to be in low 130's at least.
Sweet spot going back a few years is actually around the 139 mark,
Last edited by Quevega; 12 January 2022, 03:37 PM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Quevega View Post
Belfast Banter was fortunate to get in.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ComplyOrDie View Post
It's kinda irrelevant because we do have his breeding, but if I had to look on form alone he doesn't interest me for the County at all, especially off 139. He's been beating low level horses over 2m, and has a high enough mark for doing so. I've looked at the form, and noted what he has beat and what they've gone on to do, and the majority need or have produced over further. If he's an out and out 2 miler he needs to be having the speed and pace to be beating them further, IMO.
If he was being primed for the County I'd be wanting a Belfast Banter rating of around 129, for a novice, like him. He's 2lbs higher than Saint Roi when he ran in the race, and on what we've seen (manner of victories) I'd have him in no way close to him. The only way I see enough improvement in him for a festival race is a step up in trip, and the Martin Pipe has that ceiling of 145, so you know the rough level you're aiming at, which is what Gordon is so good at.
As I've said before, I may be way off the mark, but I won't be backing for the County Hurdle, regardless, and will congratulate those that have should he end up winning it
Belfast Banter was an outlier as you'd rarely get in on 129 in a normal year.
Comment
-
Originally posted by JackieMoon33 View Post
It's not irrelevant as the forum is littered with wrongly assumed trips based on breeding and I'm guilty as much as the next man. Breeding is only part of the equation and there is nothing conclusive on that front to suggest a step up is what he's crying out for. The eye test on the other hand gives an indication of a powerful traveller with a turn of foot and CD experience (albeit not the same 'course' as the County but I don't think that will inconvenience him). If you watch his races back and read the comments, he does need to be delivered late and is a bit of an idler, therefore his winning margins are never going to be huge regardless of racing against stayers. If anything, racing stayers would inconvenience him more as he's likely to go past them earlier.
Belfast Banter was an outlier as you'd rarely get in on 129 in a normal year.
I've been and watched the replays of his runs, and I think he travels well enough that a step up in trip would suit him really well (my confirmation bias creeping in).
As I noted to Quevega, the point in relation to Belfast Banter is where I think his rating should be for what he's actually achieved, which is also why I think the Martin Pipe would be more appropriate for him as it has a 'ceiling' on rated horses (145), whereas the County is a completely open handicap.
I actually just been through the last 10 winners of the race and with the exception of Saint Roi (surprise, surprise, a Willie Mullins horse), the other 9 winners have run in a Graded race of some sorts, previously at some point to winning it. Saint Roi, was, what I would call, a proper plot, a bit like Galopin Des Champs, last season, in the Martin Pipe.
Not that it should have an awful lot of relevance, but Petit Mouchoir, last season, was the closest Gordon (obviously ran under Denise Foster) has come to winning the County Hurdle. I don't think it's a race he has much success in, and a 139 rated novice hurdler, who has average winning form, definitely does not appeal to me.
FWIW, Belfast Banter running off 129, isn't actually the lowest rated in the last 3 seasons, as Chieftain's Choice ran off 127 in 2019. The lowest ratings to be able to get in to a County are very up and down, and literally just depend on the year.Last edited by ComplyOrDie; 13 January 2022, 09:31 AM.
Comment
Comment