Originally posted by Saxon Warrior
View Post
Riding on the back of SW's excellent Champion Chase study I was curious to find out if there is any common thread linking the 16 horses who placed after starting the season with a rating of 160 or less.
The answer is that 12 of them boasted strong form at previous Festivals - finishing in the first 4 either over hurdles or fences. or both.
Of the remaining 4 horses only Sir Valentino came out of the blue and was making his course debut. The other 3 all had decent course form.
Previous Arkle form is the most significant factor. Eight of the 16 finished in the first four in the Arkle
The fact that 75 per cent of these horses had good Festival form is maybe to be expected.
But it does provide a strong pointer about which horses may spring a surprise next year - and which potential candidates can be ruled out with a reasonable degree of confidence.
Here is the Cheltenham Festival history of the 16 horses before they placed in the Champion Chase.
Dynamite Dollars 2nd 2020 Champion Chase: 2nd to Lalor in 20k novice chase at November meeting.
Bun Doran 3rd 2020: 2nd in the 2019 Grand Annual, 6th in the 2018 Close Bros.
Sceau Royal 3rd 2019: 12th in Triumph, 6th in Champion Hurdle, Won 2 hurdle races at the track
Fox Norton 2nd 2017: 3rd in the Arkle and 3 times course winner over fences.
Min 2nd 2018: 2nd in Supreme
Gods Own 3rd 2018: 2nd in Arkle, 5th and 4th in Champion Chase
Sir Valentino 3rd 2017: First appearance at the track.
Dodging Bullets 1st 2015: 4th in Triumph, 9th in Supreme, 4th in Arkle and chase winner at the track.
Special Tiara 3rd 2015, won 2017: 15l 6th in the 2014 Champion Chase
Somersby 2nd 2014 and 2015: 3rd in the Supreme, 2nd in the Arkle, 5th in the Champion Chase, 7th Ryanair, Unseated Champions Chase
Module 3rd 2014: 4th in the Jewson, won 2m 1f handicap hurdle
Finians Rainbow 1st in 2012: 5th in Neptune, 2nd in Arkle
Sizing Europe 1st 2011: Won Arkle, 1st in Greatwood Hurdle, 14th in Champion Hurdle
Captain Cee Bee 3rd 2011: Won Supreme, 8th in Arkle
Forpadydeplasterer 2nd in 2010: 4th in Balymore, won the Arkle
Kalahari King 3rd in 2010: 4th in the Supreme, 2nd in the Arkle.
Conclusions:
If a horse with a current chase rating of 160 or less makes the frame in next year's Champion Chase the biggest clue is likely to be it's strong performance at this year's Festival or the 2019 version.
Of the 7 horses SW mentioned as fitting the profile on the Oddschecker CC market only 4 fit the bill with regard to their Cheltenham/Festival form: Put The Kettle On, Fakir D'Oudairies, Melon and Chosen Mate.
Notebook's 6th in the Arkle and 12th in the Ballymore just doesn't look good enough.
Cashback was well beaten when he fell in the Arkle.
Global Citizen was nearly 20 lengths back in 4th in the Arkle and was previously beaten 74l in the Champion Hurdle.
It's also unlikely Melon will revert to 2m next March after his gallant 2nd in the Marsh and Willie mentioning a future tilt at the Gold Cup.
But PTKO, Fakir and Chosen Mate are all possibilities.
Others who could fit the bill include Duc Des Genievres who was 5th in the Ryanair this year - appearing not to stay. He previously won the Arkle and was 5th in the Ballymore and is now rated 159 over fences.
Another possible is Samcro in the unlikely event they stepped back in trip after his Marsh and Ballymore wins.
But I'm struggling to find other potential candidates - what have I missed??
The two that interest me most at this stage are PTKO and Fakir at 20-1 and 25-1 respectively, which is decent value.
I specially like Fakir but still worry he may end up in the Ryanair (or even the GC). I've got him covered in both those events and have lobbed 1.6pts on at 15.3-1 (with boost) TWAR to balance my own bets should he end up in the Champion.
But I'll probably have a dabble on PTKO before too long - specially if Aramon wins the Galway Hurdle!
Comment