Announcement

Collapse

Fat Jockey Patrons

Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated.
Become a Patron!

You can also make a one-off donation here:
See more
See less

Mares Novice Hurdle 2020

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Tbf Hugh put me on it! Really starting to sweat with HDB tonget his 3rd winner! Was counting my money after day one!

    Comment


    • Boooom!
      33/1

      Comment


      • Interested to hear peoples views on this race, do we think this years renewal was very average given last years second annihilated them with ease, or do people think concertista being a year older than dolcita and having a lot more experience was a big factor? Main reasoning behind this question is the big disparity in odds between them for next years mares with dolcita available at 50/1. Do many think dolcita could improve past concertista next season?

        Comment


        • Originally posted by riccirich View Post
          Interested to hear peoples views on this race, do we think this years renewal was very average given last years second annihilated them with ease, or do people think concertista being a year older than dolcita and having a lot more experience was a big factor? Main reasoning behind this question is the big disparity in odds between them for next years mares with dolcita available at 50/1. Do many think dolcita could improve past concertista next season?
          My personal opinion is I don't think the opposition was up to much, not as 2 milers anyway, I think Concertista could well be one of them horses that just likes Cheltenham, and 2 miles in probably her trip. Dolcita looks as though she could do with further. So the step up and a year older could well help her.

          If it was the mares trip, I could see them finishing closer together for sure, over 2 miles, probably not. As you've asked about the mares price I'd say it was a fair bit too much distance between the pair for me, and I'd be backing Dolcita at the prices.

          Comment


          • I see Lamarcksie is 50/1 for the Mares Hurdle as well, that’s probably worth a 1pt no?

            Comment


            • Originally posted by FaugheenTheMachine View Post
              I see Lamarcksie is 50/1 for the Mares Hurdle as well, that’s probably worth a 1pt no?
              Could be mate, only worry she seems fragile like Chacun, and we seen what happened there!

              50/1 though!

              Comment


              • Originally posted by FaugheenTheMachine View Post
                I see Lamarcksie is 50/1 for the Mares Hurdle as well, that’s probably worth a 1pt no?
                Yeah.

                Backed her once the market went up. They clearly rate her highly. Her breeding suggests she'd prefer this trip too.

                Comment


                • Last year, on her stable debut Concertista was beaten in a photo in this race. She rocked up 12 months later and has won it like she's the best novice hurdler in training. Embarrassing that D.Jacob gave her some encouragement whilst 10 lengths clear halfway up the run in.

                  She hadn't managed to win a race until that point, beaten by Black Tears who had already ran well at this years festival (albeit in a handicap) was decent-ish, but that performance looks to have come from nowhere. She's up to 147 from it (so 154 if she ran against the fellas) which isn't getting her at the top table in terms of the official rating she has and to be honest I don't know how to rate her performance.

                  Dolcita got second, backing up the incredibly dull system of backing Willie Mullins horses blindly in this race. Absolutely no reason to stop doing that and trying to spot which horses they'll be as early as possible, as despite the horse that'd beaten them both Minella Melody running, the form was quite emphatically turned around when it mattered most.


                  I feel like this was a weak division and weak race. None of the mares had beaten anything of note against the boys and as such, until I see the form tested I'll treat it with caution. I don't think Concertista would have been involved with Shishkin and Abacadabras, nor do I think she'd have put Envoi Allen away, so I'm going to ignore her for next season for now.

                  Where she slots into the Mares programme doesn't excite me too much either, I don't think she's going to be better than Benie Des Dieux and I don't think time will show her to be the best of Willie's mares that he's had win the race.

                  All that said, she's had two festival runs and beat beaten in a photo and then won by a billion miles so she'll warrent a certain amount of respect, however, shadow can be cast over the merit and strength of the races she's competed in. County Hurdle would interest me the most.... I don't think she'll be good enough for a Champion Hurdle and she's too short for the Mares Hurdle for me to consider her seriously for right now. Mullins specifically said he thinks she wants more than 2 miles pre race, but this performance may have altered that view.

                  Probably goes without saying, but as I Don't really fancy the winner going forward, I don't fancy anything in behind. If some of the beaten horses start franking the form I'll upgrade the whole lot, but not until then.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by Kevloaf View Post
                    Last year, on her stable debut Concertista was beaten in a photo in this race. She rocked up 12 months later and has won it like she's the best novice hurdler in training. Embarrassing that D.Jacob gave her some encouragement whilst 10 lengths clear halfway up the run in.

                    She hadn't managed to win a race until that point, beaten by Black Tears who had already ran well at this years festival (albeit in a handicap) was decent-ish, but that performance looks to have come from nowhere. She's up to 147 from it (so 154 if she ran against the fellas) which isn't getting her at the top table in terms of the official rating she has and to be honest I don't know how to rate her performance.

                    Dolcita got second, backing up the incredibly dull system of backing Willie Mullins horses blindly in this race. Absolutely no reason to stop doing that and trying to spot which horses they'll be as early as possible, as despite the horse that'd beaten them both Minella Melody running, the form was quite emphatically turned around when it mattered most.


                    I feel like this was a weak division and weak race. None of the mares had beaten anything of note against the boys and as such, until I see the form tested I'll treat it with caution. I don't think Concertista would have been involved with Shishkin and Abacadabras, nor do I think she'd have put Envoi Allen away, so I'm going to ignore her for next season for now.

                    Where she slots into the Mares programme doesn't excite me too much either, I don't think she's going to be better than Benie Des Dieux and I don't think time will show her to be the best of Willie's mares that he's had win the race.

                    All that said, she's had two festival runs and beat beaten in a photo and then won by a billion miles so she'll warrent a certain amount of respect, however, shadow can be cast over the merit and strength of the races she's competed in. County Hurdle would interest me the most.... I don't think she'll be good enough for a Champion Hurdle and she's too short for the Mares Hurdle for me to consider her seriously for right now. Mullins specifically said he thinks she wants more than 2 miles pre race, but this performance may have altered that view.

                    Probably goes without saying, but as I Don't really fancy the winner going forward, I don't fancy anything in behind. If some of the beaten horses start franking the form I'll upgrade the whole lot, but not until then.
                    Agree with all of that but would be interested to see how Colreevy does back up in trip next season. Has come cracking bumper form and will be more at home over 2 mile 4+

                    Comment


                    • Yeah I agree regarding Concertista, not sure where she ranks, but can't imagine it will be at the top.

                      Fine performance in the race though, previous experience probably helped a fair amount too.

                      Comment


                      • Has there been an update on gypsy Island please anyone Do we know if she’s likely to make the season cheers

                        Comment


                        • Bon Retour who was very impressive in Galway after her run , could she possibly go down this route .
                          What Willie said After the race at Galway Wed, 29th Jul, 2020
                          “ She seemed to be following Danny's (Mullins, on Summer Hill) horse by jumping to her left but she has never shown done that at home and I schooled her myself this morning and she was fine. We were happy enough with her French mark of 121 and it was great to win from it and hopefully she will improve and go forward again. She is with us a few months and she will jump a fence as well. I wouldn't imagine easier ground would be an issue for her and she wouldn't have run on quick ground.” W P Mullins

                          Comment


                          • I've had a small bet on Carrigeen Lotus for this race.
                            Trained by R.H.Lalor , ( no. i know he isn't willie mullins ! ).
                            Apparently a half sister ??, to Minella Indo , at 66-1 , I'll take my chance.
                            came 3rd behind Darling daughter ( gord elliott ) at Leopardstown in feb.

                            Comment


                            • Shewearsitwell currently 12/1 (Bet365) for Mares Novice hurdle won well today in Sligo . Willie says he looking forward to running her over a 2m 4 trip !!.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by BlueGrattan View Post
                                Shewearsitwell currently 12/1 (Bet365) for Mares Novice hurdle won well today in Sligo . Willie says he looking forward to running her over a 2m 4 trip !!.
                                Probably 1 of the 8 of Mullins runners on the day. Need to get them all in the Bank.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X