If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Announcement
Collapse
Fat Jockey Patrons
Fat Jockey is a horse racing community focused on all the big races in the UK and Ireland. We don't charge users but if you have found the site useful then any support towards the running costs is appreciated. Become a Patron!
I have no idea if this falls under 'stupid questions' but I'm sure I'll find out
How rare/common is it for the handicapper to raise a veteran horse aged 11 or older 12lbs+? (Minellacelebration)
Hadn’t seen that, but that is extremely rare.
Most veterans wins command 4/5/6lb penalties because the handicapper has years of form to compare against, 12lb is obscene unless the horse was dropped significantly for being off the track for a while.
Owners every right to be unhappy...
Hadn’t seen that, but that is extremely rare.
Most veterans wins command 4/5/6lb penalties because the handicapper has years of form to compare against, 12lb is obscene unless the horse was dropped significantly for being off the track for a while.
Owners every right to be unhappy...
Cheers Ista, I thought so. It was definitely a justified hike IMO. Pissed up for a veteran and left some decent subsequent winners in behind
Cheers Ista, I thought so. It was definitely a justified hike IMO. Pissed up for a veteran and left some decent subsequent winners in behind
Hcap doesn't factor age into it, just rates what a horse does(in theory) anyway.Vieux Lion Rouge got 12lbs the other month after a huge margin win which basically makes him life very tough for the for the next Year(find out later if that starts to be true). Sounds like connections don't mind as it guaranteed him entry into the GN again thou.
Hcap doesn't factor age into it, just rates what a horse does(in theory) anyway.Vieux Lion Rouge got 12lbs the other month after a huge margin win which basically makes him life very tough for the for the next Year(find out later if that starts to be true). Sounds like connections don't mind as it guaranteed him entry into the GN again thou.
That's a given, I was on about how rare is it for an older horse to find that kind of improvement in the handicappers eyes. Interesting you mention VLR cause he walloped him before he came out and won next time up.
That's a given, I was on about how rare is it for an older horse to find that kind of improvement in the handicappers eyes. Interesting you mention VLR cause he walloped him before he came out and won next time up.
It no doubt is rare and i don't have the figures but it emphasises my feelings that this season the hcapper has been taking a very literal view on far too much, Minella being one such example. Of course if he goes close today i can take it on the chin that the hcapper was right with this horse but as a whole I've taken a dim view on the hcapper this season.
It no doubt is rare and i don't have the figures but it emphasises my feelings that this season the hcapper has been taking a very literal view on far too much, Minella being one such example. Of course if he goes close today i can take it on the chin that the hcapper was right with this horse but as a whole I've taken a dim view on the hcapper this season.
It's probably not rare but equally a little bit unusual. I think he'll go seriously close today
Hcap doesn't factor age into it, just rates what a horse
I’m not convinced that’s the case Outlaw, perhaps that’s true if older horses who have missed chunks of time or were very late switching to fences.
You gave the Vieux Lion Rouge example, Perfect Candidate won a competitive handicap chase by 45l a few weeks back and went up 8lb, a performance that could easily have commanded more but for a horse in his 8th/9th season to win that far those behind must have underperformed and I think that’s the view the handicapper took in ‘only’ raising him 8lb....
I’m not convinced that’s the case Outlaw, perhaps that’s true if older horses who have missed chunks of time or were very late switching to fences.
You gave the Vieux Lion Rouge example, Perfect Candidate won a competitive handicap chase by 45l a few weeks back and went up 8lb, a performance that could easily have commanded more but for a horse in his 8th/9th season to win that far those behind must have underperformed and I think that’s the view the handicapper took in ‘only’ raising him 8lb....
Hence my reasoning of it being very harsh on VLR as that race when you compared it on the card wasn't out the ordinary and thus plenty in it underwhelmed plus 6 didn't finish. The very first point on the BHA website states " Every horse will be treated fairly and with the highest level of integrity at all times, strictly on the merit of its form and using good handicapping practice" All they can do is on what happens or at least that's what they should try too.
I haven't put figures on PC win so not going to comment on that one.
We process personal data about users of our site, through the use of cookies and other technologies, to deliver our services, personalize advertising, and to analyze site activity. We may share certain information about our users with our advertising and analytics partners. For additional details, refer to our Privacy Policy.
By clicking "I AGREE" below, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our personal data processing and cookie practices as described therein. You also acknowledge that this forum may be hosted outside your country and you consent to the collection, storage, and processing of your data in the country where this forum is hosted.
Comment